diff --git a/docs/source/faq.rst b/docs/source/faq.rst index cc9e5b60..b506514c 100644 --- a/docs/source/faq.rst +++ b/docs/source/faq.rst @@ -102,18 +102,16 @@ errors such as ``[400 MEDIA_EMPTY]``. The only exception are stickers' file ids; you can use them across different accounts without any problem, like this one: ``CAADBAADyg4AAvLQYAEYD4F7vcZ43AI``. -Can I use Bot API's file_ids in Pyrogram? ------------------------------------------ +Can I use Bot API's file_id values in Pyrogram? +----------------------------------------------- -:strike:`Definitely! All file ids you might have taken from the Bot API are 100% compatible and re-usable in Pyrogram.` +Definitely! All file ids you might have taken from the Bot API are 100% compatible and re-usable in Pyrogram. -Starting from :doc:`Pyrogram v0.14.1 (Layer 100) `, the file_id format of all photo-like objects has -changed. Types affected are: :obj:`~pyrogram.Thumbnail`, :obj:`~pyrogram.ChatPhoto` and :obj:`~pyrogram.Photo`. Any -other file id remains compatible with the Bot API. +**However...** Telegram is slowly changing some server's internals and it's doing it in such a way that file ids are going to break inevitably. Not only this, but it seems that the new, hypothetical, file ids could also possibly expire at anytime, thus -losing the *persistence* feature. +losing the *persistence* feature (see `What is a file_ref and why do I need it?`_). This change will most likely affect the official :doc:`Bot API ` too (unless Telegram implements some workarounds server-side to keep backwards compatibility, which Pyrogram could in turn make use of) and @@ -253,6 +251,31 @@ contact people using official apps. The answer is the same for Pyrogram too and for usernames, meeting them in a common group, have their phone contacts saved or getting a message mentioning them, either a forward or a mention in the message text. +What is a file_ref and why do I need it? +---------------------------------------- + +.. note:: + + This FAQ is currently applicable to user accounts only. Bot accounts are still doing fine without a file_ref + (even though this can change anytime since it's a Telegram's internal server behaviour). + +Similarly to what happens with users and chats which need to first be encountered in order to interact with them, media +messages also need to be "seen" recently before downloading or re-sending without uploading as new file. + +**What is it meant by "they need to be seen recently"?** + +That means you have to fetch the original media messages prior any action in order to get a valid and up to date value +called file reference (file_ref) which, in pair with a file_id, enables you to interact with the media. This file_ref +value won't last forever (usually 24h, but could expire anytime) and in case of errors you have to get a refreshed +file_ref by re-fetching the original message (fetching forwarded media messages does also work). + +**Ok, but what is a file_ref actually needed for?** + +Nobody knows for sure, but is likely because that's the correct approach for handling tons of files uploaded by users in +Telegram's cloud. Which means, as soon as the media message still exists, a valid file_ref can be obtained, otherwise, +in case there's no more messages referencing a specific media, Telegram is able to free disk space by deleting old +files. + Code hangs when I stop, restart, add/remove_handler ---------------------------------------------------